In a rhetorical world

Hypothetically speaking, you loved,
Realistically, you lied.
Hypothetically, this soul was warm,
Realistically, it died.

Hypothetically speaking, you were happy,
Realistically, you spun a plot.
Hypothetically, I was happy,
Realistically, this heart was caught.

Hypothetically speaking, all was good,
Realistically, it couldn't've been worse.
Hypothetically, there was forever,
Realistically, there was only a hearse.

Hypothetically speaking or not,
Realistically tied in a knot,
Hypothetically, for me you were there,
Realistically you became my nightmare.